Home | Welcome Guest (you are not logged in)
Register  |  Login
+ New to Jawab.pk? Click here to open help

Question

3 votes

Do Human Beings have a Free Will or their Destinies are Predetermined?

Naveed Javed | 6 years ago

Ok Fellas! This is waht i feel about this!
What I concluded from my life is our destinies are kinda pre-determined; if I look into 23 years of my life, there came so many points when I got contrary to what I always desired for, My father wanted me to become a doctor, I wanna join army but ended as a Software Engineer, also so many things I aspire for didn’t come my way; But em quite happy of where I stand currently coz I have developed the strong belief that what comes in our life is according to the will of ALLAH Almighty who is the best decision maker and what He has given to me is the best for me. Yes if we talk about good and bad, ALLAH Pak has given us wisdom and it’s how we use it; But still I’m of the opinion that what we choose is according to what ALLAH Pak has written in our fate; I’ll share a famous verse of Meer Taqi Meer!
Na`haq hum majbooron per yeh tohmat hai mukhtari ki. Jo chahay so aap karey,hum ko abas badnaam kiya ... Hope you understand the urdu! :)
This question has been edited by the user - See changes

Tags: Human  Fate  Destiny  God 

Comments
lol
ill tell you what fate is..

just let me come near you for a moment
with some sedation medication
and a torture weapon concealed...

i will do what i may
at least i assure you wont bleed

and later on to the judge i will say,
i aint sick but healed

and that it was your fault and fate
which i made sure got sealed XD


i have got some weird imagination.. i try my best not to express myself :P
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago
cryptic; )
HaroOn Dilshad | 6 years ago
LOL
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago
You were very interested in this question and thought it a serious one. But when I posted some Ayaas and Aahadees for you, you didnt show interest in those sayings. Its either you asked the question just for the sake of it or you are really not interested in those holy sayings. That's sad, watever the case is.
Osama Shah | 6 years ago
Well Brother, So sorry i didn't read your answer, its not any of the case you've discussed! :)
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago
 

Asked by: Naveed Javed | 6 years ago | Answers: 10 | Views: 3053

Answers

3 votes

Zainab Hussain | 6 years ago


This answer has been edited by the user - See changes

Answered by: Zainab Hussain | 6 years ago

3 votes

Usama Hafeez | 6 years ago

Answered by: Usama Hafeez | 6 years ago

Comments
read me out; )
HaroOn Dilshad | 6 years ago

3 votes

Zain Awan | 6 years ago

Answered by: Zain Awan | 6 years ago

Comments
Thanks for the different answer but I have a few things to say
"If everything was predetermined then it gives you an excuse to not even think for yourself" does not prove that determinism is BS. So I can't see how that's a "rational" thought.

I agree that not getting things as you wanted is no support of fate, after all someone else also "wanted" things their way and worked in the opposite direction :P

+1 for your ending, nicely said
Usama Hafeez | 6 years ago

2 votes

Munahil Murrieum | 6 years ago

Answered by: Munahil Murrieum | 6 years ago

2 votes

Osama Shah | 6 years ago

Answered by: Osama Shah | 6 years ago

Comments
He quoted "Awarding of... cannot be based on justice" from his comment above. Please read it in context where its said that such an interpretation of taqdir will make justice impossible. Heres the source, please read page 24 for more details: http://annurlibrary.com/download/E-17.pdf
Usama Hafeez | 6 years ago
Server not found
HaroOn Dilshad | 6 years ago
tnx
HaroOn Dilshad | 6 years ago
+1. And Thanks for sharing such authentic proofs to my point of view!
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago

1 votes

Aasiyah Espina | 6 years ago

Answered by: Aasiyah Espina | 6 years ago

Comments
Ok Fellas! I share my thots in explanation about this! Thanks
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago
Agreed, We have a power to chose, power to think, where does that happen or not is Allah's will.
Zainab Hussain | 6 years ago

1 votes

Awais Amjad | 6 years ago

Answered by: Awais Amjad | 6 years ago

Comments
Ok Fellas! I share my thots in explanation about this! Thanks
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago

1 votes

Nabeha | 6 years ago

Answered by: Nabeha | 6 years ago

Comments
thanks for being so considerate people :)
abhi break khatam ho gaii.... wapis aa ke parhta hoon!
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago
@ Ali
about limitation of God.. Check the last para of my answer ;)
Zain Awan | 6 years ago
yup zain.. sometimes i pose questions just to poke people and make them explore.. i am delighted to see people here are pretty rational.. something which i feel is not representative of our general population. i have read your post... thats the only way i reconcile myself with the dilemma. :)
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago
Jeez if it weren't for our savior Ali :D
Usama Hafeez | 6 years ago
wuhhooo!!!
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago

0 votes

Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago

Answered by: Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago

Comments
Ali! Well man its a serious question :)
Naveed Javed | 6 years ago
yup, its a serious question... and its one of the rare types, the answer to which complicates much and solves nothing. :P
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago
Why should it be avoided?
Fahd Rasheed | 6 years ago
o baba.. agar kahin parh liya to kia gunah ho gaya..
i call it a poking suggestion.. it always starts with suna hai. and is used to convey an idea which the speaker isnt sure he can back up with evidence, probably because he hasent seen the reference or has forgotten. and i for one use it alot in verbal conversations :P
Ali Iqbal | 6 years ago
oh this topic is so interesting and discussion here is rocking....let me finish my work and I am going to join you ppl too :D until then, Ali and others - ask your free will to join me later ;)
Sumi | 6 years ago

0 votes

Faiq Latifi | 6 years ago

Answered by: Faiq Latifi | 6 years ago

Answer
You are NOT logged in. Your answer will have to be approved by a moderator first.
Please Register in order to post right away and gain Hikmat while doing so! It takes only 15 seconds!
You are seeing this Captcha because you are an anonymous user.
Please Register to remove these